Oscar Hoffman, an excellent Professor of Sociology at the Bucharest University, kept telling us, his students:
“For a proposition to be ‘true’ it is not enough for it to be ‘logical’, it also has to make sense from the epistemological point of view.”
Rather hard to swallow, specially for young individuals… and since most students tend to be … well… at least young at heart… it wasn’t simple for us to follow him.
Here’s a story that might help.
“A young man knocks on the door of a great Talmudic scholar.
“Rabbi, I wish to study Talmud.”
“Have you ever studied Torah?”
“Good. I’m well versed in logic.”
“The burglar with the dirty face.”
“Very clever. Another question please.”
“We established that. The burglar with the clean face washes.”
“I didn’t think of that. Please ask me another.”
“Rabbi, please, give me one more test.”
“But you’ve just given me four contradictory answers to the same question! That’s impossible!”
OK, but where’s the promised link?
Well, who wrote the Talmud in the first place?
A countless number of people who have figured out there’s no such thing as a definitive answer for any question?
That books should be written to help other people develop their minds, not to ‘mold’ them?
That books should be read as an exercise for the ‘thinking muscle’, not in (vain) search for ‘the absolute wisdom’?
Still looking for that link?
Keep reading, only take greater care when choosing them books.
(another version of the same story ends up like this:
“Goldstein is desperate. “I am qualified to study Talmud. Please give me one more test.”
“Neither one washes his face.”
May we all have the wisdom to ask, and answer, the wise questions!)


“Now I’m in deep doo doo!” thinks the dog, and starts racking his brain to figure a way out of his dire situation. He notices some bones nearby, and an idea hits him: He settles down comfortably to chew on the bones, with his back to the leopard. Just as the leopard is about to pounce, the dog exclaims loudly: “Man, that was one delicious leopard I just ate! I wonder if there’s any more around here?

