We, humans, pride ourselves on many things.
On being smart/intelligent. And on being the only animals able to brag about their achievements with their peers…
But what is it that qualifies us as humans?
That would, of course, depend on what a human really is…
OK, let me use another tack.
What are we really good at? What sets us apart from the rest of the animals?
Practical intelligence? Our ability to solve really complicated problems?
Then watch this wild New Caledonian Crow treating itself to a piece of meat.
Our ability to figure new meaning and to overcome our natural impulses?
Then read about Sheba the Chimp using language to suppress her greed:
SALLY BOYSEN: And Sheba gets two, so Sarah gets four. See?
SALLY BOYSEN: You want to give two to Sarah? Okay. Two goes to Sarah, and you get six.
There is a video which depicts all this. Click on this link and see if it’s available “in your area.” http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/nature/ape-genius.html.
How about our consciousness? Our ability to ‘observe ourselves in the act of observing‘.
Well, that alone wouldn’t have made us any more special than an octopus…
But what if our individuality resides in us having taken all three to ‘a different level’? One which hasn’t yet been attained by anybody else? Not necessarily higher, mind you!
I’ll deal with ‘trade’ now and I’m afraid you’ll have to come back for the rest.
‘Trade’ wasn’t even mentioned in those three examples?
What was the crow trying to do?
Feed itself? As in exchange matter with the ‘outside’?
What was Sheba trying to do?
Figure our what was going on? As in trading information with the surrounding world?
In this sense all living things are engaged in all forms of trading? And continue to do so for as long as they remain alive?
What did I tell you about us doing nothing really new? Only different?
OK, we had already figured out – long before Adam Smith described it as ‘division of labor’, that by dividing tasks amongst us we’ll be able to accomplish far more things than if we had attempted ‘individual autarky’. And then we had invented ‘trade’, as a manner of exchanging the different wares each of us was proficient in doing…
Wait! Even this is not really ‘new’!
Mother Nature had already invented sexual reproduction – a very extreme ‘division of labour’, a very long time ago…. but not before bacteria were already adept at ‘trading’ genetic information.
This the documentary where you can watch Sheeba being able to suppress her greed only when having to deal with symbols instead of actual candy.
That part starts at 28:01 but I strongly recommend the entire film.
LikeLike
And here is an academic paper by Boysen and Berntson on the same topic
Click to access 46b68b3a33f1bcf08495e86c75a06d2abe23.pdf
LikeLike
[…] I promised you some time ago, let’s have a look at […]
LikeLike
[…] The Chimp I mentioned earlier? Who was able to tame her greed by making good use of symbolic reckoning? […]
LikeLike